The Caribbean is not one place but a long arc of very different islands. Coral islands lie low on the water in the north, their sand white and their shallows clear enough to read; volcanic islands rise green and steep through the Windwards; and off the coast of Central America the Belize Barrier Reef runs for mile after mile beside the cays. What they share is the trade wind, the warmth of the water and a dry season that settles in around December. The art is to choose the island for how you wish to live, and then the house.
In the Grenadines of St Vincent, Mustique is a private island that still behaves like one: limited access, quiet roads and villas above their own coves, which we arrange privately, villa by villa. A short hop south on Canouan, Mandarin Oriental, Canouan is an estate above Godahl Beach and the reef that keeps its water unusually calm, with suites, penthouses and Signature Villas with their own pools.
Further north, in Turks & Caicos, Amanyara keeps timber-shingled pavilions and villas on the secluded northwest coast of Providenciales, facing Northwest Point Marine National Park across about half a mile of white sand. On the north coast of the Dominican Republic, Amanera holds a stretch of cliff and jungle above Playa Grande, with casitas, a serious spa and golf at a humane pace.
Dominica, the Nature Island, is the wildest of them: rainforest, 365 rivers, hot springs and the world’s second-largest boiling lake. There, Secret Bay keeps freestanding villas with private plunge pools on a rainforest promontory above the Caribbean Sea. And off Belize, Cayo Espanto is a cay of its own, minutes by boat from San Pedro, where the private island resort of Cayo Espanto keeps a handful of villas with plunge pools and piers over clear water.
For anglers, Bair’s Lodge on South Andros in the Bahamas runs skiffs from its own beach onto wide bonefish flats; our Journal follows the angler’s year, from bonefish flats to salmon rivers. The beach houses are gathered in Island Sanctuaries, and the Caribbean Water journey links Canouan, Turks & Caicos and the Dominican Republic in eight nights.